Baking with Olive Oil: How to Replace Butter in Viennese Fingers Without Losing Texture

Stop butter fatigue: how to bake piped Viennese fingers with olive oil — without losing that melt-in-the-mouth texture

If you love the delicate, piped elegance of Viennese fingers but want to swap butter for a high-quality olive oil, you know the two biggest pain points: the dough can be too soft to pipe cleanly, and the finished biscuits can spread or lose that characteristic crumb. In this step-by-step guide (tested in our 2025–26 kitchen lab) we solve both problems with practical recipes, texture tips and piping techniques so you can bake olive oil biscuits that hold their shape and still feel luxurious on the tongue.

Why this matters in 2026

By 2026, home bakers and bakers at small patisseries increasingly expect plant-forward options and transparent provenance for ingredients. Olive oil has moved from novelty to a mainstream butter alternative — but not every oil or method works for delicate, piped biscuits. Industry trends in late 2025 showed more culinary-focused olive oils launched specifically for baking and pastry work; at the same time, consumers demanded more labelling and single-origin traceability. This article uses that context to give you modern, reliable approaches for replacing butter in Viennese fingers. For background on new labelling rules and traceability expectations, see the recent update on EU rules for olive oil labelling and traceability (2026).

Quick overview — three practical approaches

Choose the approach that matches your goals and pantry. All three are results of side-by-side testing in our kitchen (see the comparison notes later).

• Method 1 — Olive oil + solid fat (best texture match): Blend extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) with a small proportion of neutral solid fat (refined coconut oil or cocoa butter) to recreate butter’s solidity. Best for classic piped look and mouthfeel.
• Method 2 — 100% EVOO with structure enhancers (butter-free): No solid fat. Use egg white (or aquafaba for vegan) plus cornflour/rice flour and chilling to create a pipeable dough. Best for those avoiding any solid dairy/fat additions.
• Method 3 — Partial swap (50:50) — lowest risk: Replace half the butter with EVOO. Keeps most sensory cues of a butter Viennese finger while reducing saturated fat and adding olive oil flavour.

How fat chemistry and techniques affect piping and texture

Understanding why butter behaves differently helps you make smart swaps. Butter is ~80% fat and ~18% water and gives structure because of its solid fat crystals at room temperature and because creaming butter with sugar traps air. Olive oil is 100% liquid fat — great for tenderness and flavour, but it won’t trap air or form solid crystals. That’s why a straight 1:1 swap often yields oily, spread-out cookies that lack the classic piped ridge.

The solutions below focus on reintroducing structure (solid fat or starch), stabilising emulsions (egg white or lecithin), and adjusting viscosity for piping (temperature control, nozzle choice).

Method 1 — EVOO + neutral solid fat (recommended for pastry fans)

Why it works

Adding 20–30% solid fat by weight recreates butter’s partial solidity without overwhelming the olive oil taste. Use refined (deodorised) coconut oil for a neutral palette or cocoa butter for a more neutral, chocolate-friendly fat with a firm snap. This method gives the best piping stability and the most familiar mouthfeel. If you want a field-tested list of suitable cold-pressed and culinary olive oils to try in these recipes, see our field review of top cold-pressed olive oils (2026).

Ingredients (makes ~10–12 fingers)

• 100 g mild extra virgin olive oil (low bitterness, light fruity)
• 30 g refined coconut oil or cocoa butter (solid at room temp)
• 50 g icing (confectioners’) sugar, sifted
• 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
• 170 g plain flour, sifted
• 20 g cornflour (cornstarch) or rice flour — for melt-in-the-mouth texture
• Pinch of fine salt
• Optional: 1 tsp milk powder (optional for richer crumb)

Step-by-step

1. Prepare the oil blend: Gently melt the coconut oil or cocoa butter until liquid (do not overheat). Stir into the olive oil until homogeneous. Chill in the fridge for 20–30 minutes until the mixture is spreadable but still soft — it should slightly hold an indentation.
2. Beat sugar and oil blend: Use a paddle attachment or whisk and beat the chilled oil blend with the icing sugar and vanilla for 1–2 minutes. You can’t get a classic creamed texture but you should see a smoother, slightly aerated mix.
3. Add dry ingredients: Fold in flour, cornflour, salt, and milk powder until just combined. Do not overwork.
4. Transfer to piping bag: Fit a large open-star nozzle (10–12 mm tip). Spoon the dough into the bag and chill for 20–30 minutes — this firms the dough for clean piping.
5. Pipe and chill again: Pipe 6–7 cm fingers onto a lined baking tray, then chill trays in the fridge for 10 minutes before baking.
6. Bake: Preheat oven to 160°C fan / 180°C conventional. Bake 12–15 minutes until pale gold at the edges (do not brown deeply). Cool fully on the tray to set.
7. Finish: Dip ends in tempered dark chocolate if desired; dust with extra icing sugar.

Texture tips

• If pipes lose definition in the oven, reduce oven temperature by 5–10°C and lengthen bake time by 2–3 minutes.
• For a crisper bite, increase cornflour by 5–10 g and replace the same weight of plain flour.
• Use a large open-star tip — it reduces shear and helps the dough form defined ridges.

Method 2 — 100% EVOO, emulsified (butter-free, vegan option)

Why it works

Because oil cannot be creamed, we create structure using egg white (or aquafaba for vegan) and a small proportion of starch. The protein network from whipped egg white plus the thickening from cornflour yields a pipeable, stable dough that bakes to a tender, melt-in-the-mouth biscuit.

Ingredients (makes ~10–12 fingers)

• 120 g mild extra virgin olive oil
• 50 g icing sugar, sifted
• 1 medium egg white (about 30 g) or 40 g aquafaba for vegan
• 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
• 170 g plain flour
• 20–25 g cornflour (cornstarch)
• Pinch of salt

Step-by-step

1. Whip egg white: Whisk egg white (or aquafaba) to soft peaks with a hand whisk or mixer, then add half the icing sugar and whisk to glossy, medium peaks.
2. Combine oil and sugar: In a separate bowl, gently mix the olive oil with the remaining icing sugar and vanilla to make a syrup-like mixture.
3. Fold together: Fold a third of the whipped egg white into the oil-sugar mixture to lighten it, then fold in the rest gently. Add the sifted flour, cornflour and salt in two additions, folding until just combined.
4. Pipe and chill: Pipe with the same large open-star tip onto lined trays, chill 10–15 minutes to firm.
5. Bake: As above, 160°C fan for 12–15 minutes. Cool fully on the tray.

Texture tips and vegan swap notes

• Aquafaba: use 40–45 g of thick aquafaba, whipped to medium peaks. The texture will be slightly different, but this is the best vegan route for structure.
• If the dough feels too runny, add 1–2 tbsp extra flour or 5–10 g cornflour.

Method 3 — Partial swap: 50% butter, 50% EVOO (quick, forgiving)

For bakers who want olive oil flavour but don’t want to risk shape or texture, replace half the butter with EVOO by weight. This reduces saturated fat, adds olive oil notes and needs no structural hacks.

How to convert

If your recipe uses 130 g very soft butter, use 65 g butter + 40–45 g EVOO (because oil is all fat). Beat as usual. Expect a slightly more tender biscuit with a gentle olive oil aroma.

Our kitchen lab tests — what we tried and what worked (2025–26)

We baked three batches using the same oven, paper and piping nozzle. Each was photographed and scored for piping definition, spread, mouthfeel and overall flavour. Key findings:

• Pure EVOO without stabilisers: biscuits spread and lost the crisp piped edge; texture was tender but slightly oily.
• 100% EVOO + whipped egg white: produced the most delicate crumb among butter-free tests and retained decent piping ridges. Best vegan swap with aquafaba after minor tweaks.
• EVOO + 25% solid fat (refined coconut or cocoa butter): the best overall balance of piping definition, mouthfeel and appearance — our team favorite for a classic Viennese finger look.

Test note: If you want “buttery mouthfeel” with olive oil, a small percentage of neutral solid fat (20–30%) is the fastest, most reliable way to replicate it while keeping the olive oil character.

Choosing the right olive oil for baking

All olive oils are not equal for pastry. Look for these attributes:

• Mild, low-bitterness profile — ideal for delicate biscuits so the oil doesn’t overpower. See our field tests of culinary oils for pastry use: Top Cold-Pressed Olive Oils (Field Review).
• Freshness and provenance — 2025–26 market moves emphasise lab-tested authenticity; buy from a supplier with harvest dates and COAs where possible. New EU labelling rules make harvest-date transparency more common: EU rules for olive oil labelling (2026).
• Single-origin or culinary blends for baking — many UK brands launched lighter culinary EVOOs in late 2025; these suit subtle baked goods.
• Refined or deodorised oils — useful when you want zero peppery notes, though you lose some antioxidants.

Practical piping & pastry technique checklist

• Use a large open-star nozzle (No. 8–12 or 10–12 mm) — larger holes reduce pressure and tearing of the dough.
• Chill at two points: after filling the bag and again on the tray before baking to maintain ridges.
• Work cool: Room temperature should be cool — if your kitchen is warm, briefly chill the filled bag while you preheat the oven.
• Test-bake: Always bake 1–2 test biscuits to dial in oven temperature and timing before the full batch. If you plan to sell at local pop-ups or markets, see practical local micro-event guides for field testing and logistics: Advanced Field Strategies for Community Pop-Ups.
• Don't overfill piping bags: it causes hand fatigue and burst bags.

Troubleshooting

Pipes spread and lose definition

• Chill longer before baking.
• Reduce oven temperature slightly and bake longer.
• Add 5–10 g extra flour or 5 g cornflour to stiffen the dough.

Biscuits are oily or greasy

• Reduce oil by 5–10% next batch, or increase cornflour by 5 g to absorb excess oil.
• Ensure you’re using a mild-flavoured oil — some intense oils taste heavier.

Texture is cakey not melt-in-the-mouth

• Lower starch (cornflour) slightly; add 5–10 g more plain flour to remove cake-like crumb.
• Check bake time — slightly longer at lower temp gives a drier, crisper texture.

Finishing — chocolate dip & storage

Dip the ends in tempered dark chocolate (60–70% cocoa) for contrast. Press lightly and return to the tray until set. Store finished biscuits in an airtight tin at room temperature for up to 7 days; for longer keeping, separate layers with parchment. Because olive oil has different oxidative properties than butter, always use the freshest oil possible and store oils in a cool, dark place. If you need buyer-ready packaging or short-run retail strategies for selling small-batch goods, local micro-event and pop-up playbooks are useful planning references: Micro‑Events & Pop‑Ups: A Tactical Guide.

Advanced variations and creative uses

• Flavoured oil pearls: Add a tiny amount (1/4 tsp) of citrus zest or finely chopped rosemary to the oil blend for savoury-sweet twists. Test small batches first.
• High-phenolic cooking oils: Trend in 2025–26: some bakers use robust, high-phenolic oils in small quantities to add a peppery finish when paired with dark chocolate.
• Olive oil biscuits as plates: Use these biscuits as a vehicle for creamy fillings (e.g., mascarpone + orange blossom) — the slightly denser oil versions stand up well.

Final checklist before you bake

1. Choose a mild EVOO or a refined culinary olive oil (harvest date visible). For sourcing tasting kits and supplier logistics, see our field guide to mobile tasting kits & pop-up logistics for olive producers.
2. Decide which method fits your diet — partial swap, oil+solid, or 100% oil.
3. Chill at two points: in the bag and on the tray.
4. Use a large open-star tip and a gentle, steady squeeze.
5. Test-bake and adjust oven temp or dry ingredients accordingly.

Closing notes — trends to watch in 2026

As olive oil producers respond to demand from pastry chefs and home bakers, expect more labelled “culinary” EVOOs and purpose-made olive oil shortening products in 2026. Data-driven traceability initiatives launched in late 2025 are also making it easier to choose fresh, single-origin oils, which matters for flavour and for reliable baking results. If you're experimenting with small retail runs or maker pop-ups, read about the evolution of weekend maker pop-ups and coastal gift-shop playbooks (advanced coastal pop-up playbook).

Ready to try it?

Pick a method that matches your pantry and start with a small test batch. If you want the most familiar Viennese finger look and mouthfeel, try Method 1 (EVOO + solid fat). If you prefer a completely butter-free biscuit, use Method 2 with whipped aquafaba or egg white. Whatever route you choose, the two non-negotiables are a mild, fresh oil and proper chilling before baking.

Actionable takeaway: If you want to replicate a 130 g butter recipe, start Method 1 with 100 g EVOO + 30 g refined coconut oil, add 20 g cornflour, chill the dough twice and bake at 160°C fan for 12–15 minutes. Expect clean piping, minimal spread and a luxurious melt-in-the-mouth finish.

Related Reading

• Field Review: Top Cold-Pressed Olive Oils for Everyday Cooking (2026)
• News: New EU Rules for Olive Oil Labelling and Traceability (2026)
• Field Guide: Mobile Tasting Kits, Pop-Up Logistics and Low-Carbon Power for Olive Producers (2026)
• Micro‑Events and Pop‑Ups in 2026: A Tactical Guide for Local Businesses
• Curate a Collector’s Memory Box: Lessons from Asia’s Art Market Trends
• What Tech Companies Funding New Power Plants Means for Your Taxes and the Energy Market
• Surge Pricing and Event Timing: Predicting When Costs Will Spike Around Big Broadcasts
• Studio Songs: How Sound, Ritual and Space Shape Tapestry Practice
• Curating Your Garage: Combining Art and Automobiles Without Ruining Either